EAST TEXAS HOG DOGGERS FORUM

HOG & DOGS => HOG DOGS => Topic started by: SpringCreek on January 30, 2018, 07:19:15 pm



Title: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: SpringCreek on January 30, 2018, 07:19:15 pm
I’m fairly new to running hog dogs, I’ve trained cattle dogs before so I am not worried about training them. My primary concern is finding dogs that will hunt close. The places I’ve already got permission to run on are  between 700-1230 acres. I don’t want rangy dogs of course. I was wondering if anyone had any recommendations on breeds to run on that size property. Pretty wooded, but not super brushy. Any and all advice is super appreciated. Thank y’all.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Judge peel on January 30, 2018, 08:11:27 pm
They come in every breed. Generally the short range dogs tend to be rough but not always


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: SpringCreek on January 30, 2018, 08:22:56 pm
All I’ve really ran behind are Lacy’s. Most of them were a little rough and hunted fairly close, but they were just not my thing I guess.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: NLAhunter on January 30, 2018, 08:40:02 pm
Probably best thing to do if you can find some people that hunt dogs like you are looking for go hunt with all you can and decide what you like

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: SpringCreek on January 30, 2018, 09:43:49 pm
That’s my issue, the only folks that run close that I know, run Lacy’s. I’m not a fan of them. Lol.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: T-Bob Parker on January 31, 2018, 03:32:23 am
almost every dog youll find for sale on here or facebook will fit the bill for staying in close range. if they weren't short ranged, they usually wouldn't be for sale. best advice I can offer you is buy 3 dogs off the public market and hunt them for the next 3 months. keep the best one, rid yourself of the other two and start fresh with two new ones and repeat.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: jsh on January 31, 2018, 04:56:38 am
My current set of dogs now do not cast out far hunting.  However, when they get into them they will stick literally for miles.  They are not rough either, so it also depends on how much the hogs run or are pressured as to how much country we’ll cover. I could never hunt 700 -1200 acres with these close hunting dogs without knowing the neighbors.  Now if I throw 2 more dogs on the ground with them, they’ll commit more physically to holding a runner.  Even if they do decide to catch, one of them rolls pretty good so then a “problem” presents itself with the close hunting dogs on small properties. It’s a tricky answer cause a lot of it depends on the hogs, how often it’s hunted, dogs and terrain.  I have one place that you can be in pigs for hours on just a few hundred acres, but it’s because of the terrain - there’s just nowhere for them to go really.

I’m not trying to discount what anyone else has said, but just because they are short range, doesn’t mean they’ll fit small properties. Like Terry said though, you’ll probably not easily find a dog for sale on here that rolls out pig after pig.......


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: TheRednose on January 31, 2018, 09:06:44 am
If I had to hunt small properties I would go to as close to straight catch dogs as I could. I would run like them Fla and Gorgia boys do with the Florida curs or bird dog/bull dog crosses. I would stay away from hounds because even a close hunting hound if it is bred well will have a lot of bottom to them. Stockdogs like bmc's might work well too, because they tend to be able to stop hogs and even though they may want to range far they are smart and can be taught to hunt the way you want I bet.

Just some thoughts, good luck.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: SpringCreek on January 31, 2018, 03:20:06 pm
I was considering finding cur/bull crosses, just kind of hard to come get it seems. Gritty, shut them down type dogs. I feel like I’d almost be better just raising my own for the task. Good game bred pit, crossed over a gritty BMC instead of just running somebody else’s culls. Hogs are pretty dense, property is fresh. I’ve worked for the neighbors and the hate pigs just as much so I can get away with crossing on a chase if I have to.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Judge peel on January 31, 2018, 03:32:09 pm
I got Florida cur x cat they decent for the job. I got mnt cur and mnt cur x stock dog. They work good for the same. Adding pit to cur won't solve anything in my opinion. Yes there are good ones of that variety. If your just wanting a dog or two that catch on sight I would just find some that are already doing it save you a lot of time and effort


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: TheRednose on January 31, 2018, 05:09:25 pm
I was considering finding cur/bull crosses, just kind of hard to come get it seems. Gritty, shut them down type dogs. I feel like I’d almost be better just raising my own for the task. Good game bred pit, crossed over a gritty BMC instead of just running somebody else’s culls. Hogs are pretty dense, property is fresh. I’ve worked for the neighbors and the hate pigs just as much so I can get away with crossing on a chase if I have to.

I've never hunted behind a BMC/Bulldog but I have see bird dog/Bulldog and they were nice. I seen a real nice straight BMC do it well too.

I would prob go the stock dog route and look for one from a long line of rough hog stoppers and then go from there. They are usually real smart and can usually learn the way you want to do things.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: warrent423 on January 31, 2018, 06:50:21 pm
A set of "rank" stock bred cur dogs, with a good handle, can be hunted effectively anywhere. Our recipe has always included bulldog in the mix. That's "Bulldog", not pit bulldog ;) Most don't know that there is a difference.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: SpringCreek on January 31, 2018, 08:31:57 pm
So a good cur with a little bulldog back in it, I can probably arrange that. Now to just track down good cur pups. When I was younger and we ran coons it was behind Stephens curs, so of course off that logic I’m learning towards trying to find some good Mt. Curs, I know they are smart as a whip, just figured they might be too rangy.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Cmwhogger on February 01, 2018, 07:51:03 am
I run mountain curs and BMC. Here in the Ozarks close range is crucial. With that being said I have some old stock mtn cur that are short range and will catch anything. I have a BMC that will range out along with a "modern" bred mtn cur but they will stick with a pig for miles. We don't run a catch dog and havnt found a pig the mtn cuts can't hold but if they don't stick together it could be a long race. You can never garauntee you will stay within a certain property.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Slim9797 on February 01, 2018, 07:58:36 am
Springcreek I sent you a message.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: bignasty on February 01, 2018, 08:06:56 am
640 acres /1 square mile
1280/2 miles



Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Judge peel on February 02, 2018, 11:08:45 am
Lot of folks run short rough dogs I wouldn't just start mixing up dogs when there already out there save you lot of time and heart ache besides the money lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: make-em-squeel on February 06, 2018, 08:25:44 pm
lol, i bet theres plenty of folks wanting to sell you a close hunting dog, their called culls with no bottom. if thats what you want go with athletic abs,dogos,game bred pits or half those/half cur or cat or bird ie outlaw curs


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: SpringCreek on February 06, 2018, 08:28:52 pm
I think I’m going to end up with a couple GSP/AB x Catahoula pups I ended up finding. I think that will work well.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Mike on February 06, 2018, 08:32:29 pm
Tone training your dogs will allow you to hunt smaller properties without sacrificing their range or bottom. I hunt lots of city places that are small and surrounded by roads... just a tone and my dogs stop and go in reverse.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: make-em-squeel on February 06, 2018, 08:42:13 pm
Tone training your dogs will allow you to hunt smaller properties without sacrificing their range or bottom. I hunt lots of city places that are small and surrounded by roads... just a tone and my dogs stop and go in reverse.

interesting... ive always been to scared to try and make my dogs short range or bump them off a track, as to what i would do to them if they minded to well lol. Where can I read about tone training, obviously you start this after they show you they hunt good??


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Mike on February 06, 2018, 09:04:04 pm
I start tone training them as soon as I start hauling them to the woods. Every time I call them to me, I'm toning them. If they don't come, give them a little shock. It doesn't take long for them to learn the tone means to come back. I can tone my older dogs off running a hog or even a bayed hog if needed. If they don't come off, shock them... they know they're getting shocked for not coming to the tone and not getting shocked off the hog. It takes some time, but it's well worth it. Saves a lot of long days or nights... and it keeps you on the right side of the law by not trespassing. And no... it does not affect their range or bottom.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Slim9797 on February 06, 2018, 10:05:53 pm
lol, i bet theres plenty of folks wanting to sell you a close hunting dog, their called culls with no bottom. if thats what you want go with athletic abs,dogos,game bred pits or half those/half cur or cat or bird ie outlaw curs
Different strokes I guess. A dog that goes 2 miles to not find anything around this yard would be deemed a cull.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Rough curs on February 06, 2018, 10:28:57 pm
100% with what Mike  said ,I run pit xmnt cur / cat  x pit  took a lil breeding for what I have now . I can catch a hog with in yards or miles depends how far I want to go , trained mine to stay with me till hogs are within reach or rig on a hot 1. If the hogs are not where I'm at then I brought the dogs to wrong place. I want too hunt the area I'm at not everything around me if that makes sense. If the dogs  go out it s game on.like Judge said different strokes for different folks


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Big Game Joe on February 08, 2018, 12:26:17 am
I agree totally with Mike also, only difference is I run rough Plotts. I usually either turn out on big tracks or at feeders/bait, if they get 150 yards from me, they are on one. They trail silent, so a lot of times we will bust him in his bed. If that happens, he ain't going nowhere. If the hog does get up and run, you have got to have the bottom to (run the air out of it.) Range is trainable in most any breed, within reason. I believe tone training is essential to hunting many of the places we hunt nowadays. Some people will say that I have too much handle on my dogs, but I would rather have it, than not have enough handle or none at all as some hunters I've seen. So in answer to the original question get you some ruff dogs and train them to hunt how YOU want them to hunt.    Mike Starling


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: make-em-squeel on February 13, 2018, 03:35:20 pm
I start tone training them as soon as I start hauling them to the woods. Every time I call them to me, I'm toning them. If they don't come, give them a little shock. It doesn't take long for them to learn the tone means to come back. I can tone my older dogs off running a hog or even a bayed hog if needed. If they don't come off, shock them... they know they're getting shocked for not coming to the tone and not getting shocked off the hog. It takes some time, but it's well worth it. Saves a lot of long days or nights... and it keeps you on the right side of the law by not trespassing. And no... it does not affect their range or bottom.

I did this with my 6 mo old pups this weekend, worked pretty good. I will continue


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Georgia-Hawgs on February 15, 2018, 11:35:06 am
That tone training is where it's at. I may be the guy on this site with the least experience training dogs. But I had a smart as a whip black mouth and he was 100% tone trained by 10 months old and it sure didn't take long. We was hunting some big farms down in South Georgia and the dogs got out by the road. I told everybody where they were and they all took off running and hollering for there dogs. The dogs were working a track and dang near a mile out. I toned my boomer dog and didnt even take a step in his direction. The land owner was with us and didnt have a dog in the hunt. He asked why I wasn't getting after my dog to. I said he's on the way back here now like a bat outta hell. And sure enough me and the land owner watched him come all the way back on the Garmin. He was sure impressed with that. 45 minutes later here come the rest of the crew and dang near to tired to keep hunting. 


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: mike rogers on March 02, 2018, 09:14:12 pm
I run leopard cur. They can range on out when hunting with go yonder dog, but hunt around 200 to 30 yards when by themselves. I hunt coons so it's a little different. LOL my game goes up a tree :)


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: jpuckett on March 05, 2018, 09:38:16 pm
MIKE, I think I’d haveta disagree with you, I do believe toning a dog off of a pig once they are on it will definitely affect their bottom over time, seen it happen, they just drop outta the race once they have hit that range. Not saying it doesn’t for ur’s but I think it would for most dogs


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: jpuckett on March 05, 2018, 09:41:15 pm
I do tone train my dogs, but I don’t think it’s a good idea to do a lot once the race is on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Mike on March 06, 2018, 09:16:38 am
Jpuckett... I'll have to disagree. I started tone training dogs probably 8 years or so back with the old Tri-Tronics Trashbreaker. My main reason back then was because I usually hunted 3 nights a week and those late nights were killing me. When I was ready to go home... I could just tone them in. Since then, it's been a great tool for hunting smaller properties, hunting near busy roads and to keep from trespassing. I've owned a few truckloads of dogs since then... the curs I breed, hounds, hound crosses and all my bulldogs. It hasn't affected the hunt or drive in any of them... once they know the tone means "come back". Whether it's five minutes into a race or five hours, doesn't matter. I also know several others that train their dogs the same with no ill effects.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: jpuckett on March 06, 2018, 09:23:32 am
That’s interesting mike, you have much more experience and my evidence is mostly anecdotal. I appreciate the reply, sounds like the couple dogs I had it happen to maybe just didn’t really have enough bottom to begin with (which is a definite possibility) I assumed it was from the tone but I could def be wrong.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Mike on March 06, 2018, 09:47:33 am
The key is to be sure they are tone trained to come in before you ever attempt to tone them off a hog. Only use the tone for that purpose. Lots of folks tone them for everything and that just confuses the dog. I've seen people tone them to "get ahead" and then turn around and tone them to come back haha. I think the worst is tone, tone, tone, then shock for running trash... if they're trashing it's straight electricity. That tone should only mean one thing... come back. The only other thing I'll tone mine for is raising hell on the buggy... one little beep and they know to shut up. It takes time, but well worth it and can save a lot of headaches and prevent some bad situations from happening.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Td3 dogs n hogs on March 06, 2018, 03:03:52 pm
    Mike,
What system would you recommend for someone looking to start tone training? Also when you tone them back to you how long does it take them to start hunting again, or is the hunt over for that dog? Im in no hurry to start toning dogs off hogs, but I recently got some places that are real good hunting just close to the highway.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Mike on March 06, 2018, 03:19:26 pm
The Garmin Alpha with TT15 collars is the best thing since sliced bread my opinion haha. I've had mine almost 5 years now and love it... but any shock collars with the tone feature  and the range will get the job done.

The hunt isn't over, just load them and move to another spot and cast again, or start roading them or rigging them... whatever style you hunt. They shouldn't quit hunting from being toned back.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Td3 dogs n hogs on March 07, 2018, 11:56:09 am
Thanks for the info.


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: hyan on March 17, 2018, 08:52:02 pm
Garmin alpha 100 train them with that n you can hunt any breed on 20 acre's to 200,000 thats the first thing mike thought me wen I hunted the city hunt near roads,homes,dog training kennels, near high fence's or any property lines just send them a text message them come right back on a hog or just out hunting


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Goose87 on March 18, 2018, 12:07:13 pm
Garmin alpha 100 train them with that n you can hunt any breed on 20 acre's to 200,000 thats the first thing mike thought me wen I hunted the city hunt near roads,homes,dog training kennels, near high fence's or any property lines just send them a text message them come right back on a hog or just out hunting



Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Black Streak on March 20, 2018, 11:07:58 pm
A dog that will bark at a big boar only invites races which often lead beyond the property boundaries.     Shocking a persueing dog off or calling it off in one way or another is not something I want to set myself up for.   Shocking a young dog off deer or stock isn't as confusing to a dog as shocking it off the quary you have spent so much effort trying get it to focus on.        Think id rather hunt a type of dog that eliminated these type issues rather than enabled them.     


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Goose87 on March 21, 2018, 06:17:45 pm
A dog that will bark at a big boar only invites races which often lead beyond the property boundaries.     Shocking a persueing dog off or calling it off in one way or another is not something I want to set myself up for.   Shocking a young dog off deer or stock isn't as confusing to a dog as shocking it off the quary you have spent so much effort trying get it to focus on.        Think id rather hunt a type of dog that eliminated these type issues rather than enabled them.   

If the handler has done the ground work at home then he has no need to “shock” a dog, people get so consumed on the whole shock hysteria when in reality the actual shocking stimulation should only be used as a last ditch effort, the tone is our way of communicating with dogs at a distance beyond ear shot, no different than two fighters stopping when they hear the bell ring or a ball player stopping play when an official blows the whistle, when those athletes were in their developing stages they were taught what those sounds meant, it doesn’t discourage them from being superior athletes, no different in dogs, I’ve seen countless times with my own dogs and others as well that are tone trained and it doesn’t mess with their performance one iota, it’s when joe blow gets out there with that fire stick in his hands thinking he’s somebody and going to solve all his problems on the first hunt right out of the gate without putting in the necessary ground work is when and where the whole “shocking” hysteria takes place...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Mike on March 21, 2018, 08:15:03 pm
Goose said it better than I could... exactly what he said. I’ve been tone training mine for years and it has no affect on their performance.

But yes.... there’s been lots of dogs ruined with shock collars in the wrong hands.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: cajunl on March 22, 2018, 07:00:04 am
Some guys I know that deer hound have there dogs tone trained. They probally run 10 does for every buck they shoot and that's being conservative. They get toned off hundred of races a year. The hounds run the next track, just as hard as the first of the day!

The beeb is just the come/here command strapped to there neck nothing more or less.



Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Black Streak on March 22, 2018, 04:35:24 pm
A dog that will bark at a big boar only invites races which often lead beyond the property boundaries.     Shocking a persueing dog off or calling it off in one way or another is not something I want to set myself up for.   Shocking a young dog off deer or stock isn't as confusing to a dog as shocking it off the quary you have spent so much effort trying get it to focus on.        Think id rather hunt a type of dog that eliminated these type issues rather than enabled them.   

If the handler has done the ground work at home then he has no need to “shock” a dog, people get so consumed on the whole shock hysteria when in reality the actual shocking stimulation should only be used as a last ditch effort, the tone is our way of communicating with dogs at a distance beyond ear shot, no different than two fighters stopping when they hear the bell ring or a ball player stopping play when an official blows the whistle, when those athletes were in their developing stages they were taught what those sounds meant, it doesn’t discourage them from being superior athletes, no different in dogs, I’ve seen countless times with my own dogs and others as well that are tone trained and it doesn’t mess with their performance one iota, it’s when joe blow gets out there with that fire stick in his hands thinking he’s somebody and going to solve all his problems on the first hunt right out of the gate without putting in the necessary ground work is when and where the whole “shocking” hysteria takes place...



I think i should have explained my opinion differently as it pertained to the original question posed by the author instead of using the collar anology so hard.   I used it because that's where people took this thread and made the collars the correction to the problem.       I was trying to show that the collars as pertained to the original question in this thread are not the cure but rather only treat the symptom. Does the collars work to bring a dog back, yes BUT working inside this man's question and scenario, collars are only treating the symptom but it's the cure he is looking and asking for.  
      As I understand the question, the man is wanting to catch pigs within a certain size property.   He not asking how do you keep the dogs on the property but rather what works best for catching pigs within the particular property size.    My point with the collars was really as follows.   If you have to call a dog off a race because of property boundaries, you didn't catch that pig.      How could we have caught that pig and dramatically or rather almost eliminate such scenarios.    It's not the collar cause the collars aren't in charge of catching the pig.  It's the dog.   Let's examine the differences in dogs and what kind of dog would cure the problem cause it's the dog thats the cure not the collar.    Collar as described here by is needed because the cure is not addressed and as typical we treating the symptoms not the cure.   Symptoms point to the problem they are not the problem.  
    How do we find and successfully catch pigs on a small property without  enabling or promoting a race which would likely lead beyond the property line.     Should we use a dog that will bark at a pig on small properties?   What happens when a dog barks at a pig?   It's totally up to the pig.    Why leave the options up to the pig?   Why allow it to dictate anything or afford it the option to run.   Is the pressure of one barking dog ok and acceptable to the pig but the pressure of 2 or more dogs there barking and harassing the pig to great for it to stay put or is that what it takes to keep this particular pig in this particular spot to stay put.    If by chance this same pig was first made contact in a different area of the property, would it in turn run because of the pressure of a barking dog or two or 4 or would it feel as comfortable here standing its ground as it does anywhere else?    Why do pigs run? For safety and because they feel threatened.    
    So working within the question posed as I read it by the author,  why leave the options and course of events once the pig is found, up to the pig.      I understand and realize that yall guys are bay dog people and bay dogs are what your familiar with.     I understand that there is a ton of misinformation and or lack of knowledge amongst the overwhelming majority of pig doggers here in the U.S. about other types and styles of pig dogs.         As a result, so many good questions are asked because the cure to certain problems is never known or is only known to be taboo within certain circles and only the symptoms to a lot of the age old problems discussed.    
    I see a lot of people thinking outside the box more and more which is great and they realize the cure to some of these problems  but don't understand what exactly the antidote really is but to really no fault of their own.     I to was once in this same position evaluating these same problems.    The solution was not as simple as first assumed but the merrits of the solution were correct.     Just took much time and understanding as to what the actual correct antidote was.  No shortcut will cure this but only get you wrecked or worse off and here lay the problem with the majority of the ones that think outside the box and realize the right solution to many of these problems but don't understand how obtain the cure.      
      Have I said what the cure is?    Not exactly.   I don't want to put the cart before the horse because what few people are genuinely interested still will skip the understanding part and go straight for the cure.   Without the understanding and patience the level of play and talent will not be achieved only the reward bought.      
    

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Goose87 on March 22, 2018, 08:09:37 pm
I don’t think anyone made the collar theory the solution, just an option for
The man to be able to contemplate using as a way to keep his dogs within certain boundaries and I can see the angle at which your approaching this without coming out and saying, “why don’t you use finder/holders”, instead in your typical style you try to cut the ones who use baydogs down and put those who use your style of dogs on a higher pedestal than the rest, rather you choose to believe me or not but I highly respect your opinions, views, and knowledge on dogs and actually have respect and admiration for your style of dogs,but they will just not be the most effective in a lot of places, maybe they will be the key to the door the original poster is trying to unlock and maybe they won’t, it’s for him to consider or try, but with all do respect there’s a place for finder holder type dogs and then there isn’t, they’re a specialized style of dogs who are suitable for only certain terrain and even though they may excell in certain areas they will not work in others, that doesn’t make them or the ones who use them any more superior than the ones who don’t, heck I even encourage the original poster to give them a try and see what he thinks...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: make-em-squeel on March 22, 2018, 08:34:08 pm
I don’t think anyone made the collar theory the solution, just an option for
The man to be able to contemplate using as a way to keep his dogs within certain boundaries and I can see the angle at which your approaching this without coming out and saying, “why don’t you use finder/holders”, instead in your typical style you try to cut the ones who use baydogs down and put those who use your style of dogs on a higher pedestal than the rest, rather you choose to believe me or not but I highly respect your opinions, views, and knowledge on dogs and actually have respect and admiration for your style of dogs,but they will just not be the most effective in a lot of places, maybe they will be the key to the door the original poster is trying to unlock and maybe they won’t, it’s for him to consider or try, but with all do respect there’s a place for finder holder type dogs and then there isn’t, they’re a specialized style of dogs who are suitable for only certain terrain and even though they may excell in certain areas they will not work in others, that doesn’t make them or the ones who use them any more superior than the ones who don’t, heck I even encourage the original poster to give them a try and see what he thinks...


I have and i like them (finder/holder), but my good bmc strike dogs will finish more tracks with a pig bayed on the end of it every time in any terrain. IMO thats when you turn your finder holder loose to them and if it breaks they will finish it, best of both worlds. Ive never had a hard finder/holder that was not a great lead in cd that worked better than a typical pit in diverse situations/runners or bay broken. I love them but my bmcs will out strike them

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Reuben on March 22, 2018, 09:59:02 pm
As the human population grows and the hunting places get smaller...at some point finder/holders and RCD type of dogs will be the best options for catching hogs...when they miss tone them back...

We all like different style of hunting dogs...I like long range stick with the track no matter what gritty dogs that don’t quit...and when the other dogs come out of the woods I can cast mine and find and Bay a Hog...opening on track now and then a plus but with the Garmin not so important to me anymore...


Title: Re: Close Hunting Dogs
Post by: Black Streak on March 22, 2018, 10:17:17 pm
I don’t think anyone made the collar theory the solution, just an option for
The man to be able to contemplate using as a way to keep his dogs within certain boundaries and I can see the angle at which your approaching this without coming out and saying, “why don’t you use finder/holders”, instead in your typical style you try to cut the ones who use baydogs down and put those who use your style of dogs on a higher pedestal than the rest, rather you choose to believe me or not but I highly respect your opinions, views, and knowledge on dogs and actually have respect and admiration for your style of dogs,but they will just not be the most effective in a lot of places, maybe they will be the key to the door the original poster is trying to unlock and maybe they won’t, it’s for him to consider or try, but with all do respect there’s a place for finder holder type dogs and then there isn’t, they’re a specialized style of dogs who are suitable for only certain terrain and even though they may excell in certain areas they will not work in others, that doesn’t make them or the ones who use them any more superior than the ones who don’t, heck I even encourage the original poster to give them a try and see what he thinks...


I have and i like them (finder/holder), but my good bmc strike dogs will finish more tracks with a pig bayed on the end of it every time in any terrain. IMO thats when you turn your finder holder loose to them and if it breaks they will finish it, best of both worlds. Ive never had a hard finder/holder that was not a great lead in cd that worked better than a typical pit in diverse situations/runners or bay broken. I love them but my bmcs will out strike them


    Sir, your idea of a finder holder is in no way what a finder holder is.     You are playing the most dangerous game in pig dogging possible.  From what you just said, you have no idea what a finder holder is or how to hunt them and why.     Sorry of I'm harsh.       What your doing is deadly to the dogs for about 7 different reasons with no real added benifit. 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro