Unplanned litter

, Here is the major problem with your scenario( in my opinion,not tyrying to start an argument) not all pups grow up to be good dogs or even mediocre dogs. So you are giving away potential culls to young hunters for free. Yes they are probaly happy to have the dogs, but the young getting started folks spend two years feeding a dog and trying to figure out why their dog is not as good as so-&- sos dog. THey can't cull a dog they raised for 2-3 years, and because they probly have not been taught about the importance of culling they pass the dog on to someonbe else, or it has an accidental litter that the kids shares the pups with all his friends.

Now the New Scenario, a bunch of young kids are running around hunting, chasing and educating pigs with mediocre dogs. These kids could have startyed with a good dog from the beggining, hopefully got from someone reputable that passed down some knowledge about responsible breeding, hunting, and keepiing records and tracking performance to build better dogs in the first place.

Now if this dogs have a record of their bloodline, and track record worth bragging about, then putting pups out there in few folks hands might not be so bad if you are going to keep track, or if its friends requesting pups is one thing but to take a kid and say here you are a great dog this is gong to be when you yourself know its a crap shoot is not right to do to an unsuspecting kid.