I can't speak for any other breed of dog but a bulldog should be held to a higher standard just like a linebred cur dog. I will cull every cur dog that I raise off the line I hunt that doesn't live up to that standard. I don't think it should be any different with a bulldog. Years of culling made them what they are and yes of course there are some sorry ones out there and that will never change. The same arguement can be made about bulldogs as it is with good linebred cur dogs. The only way to get consistency and dependability and raise your percentages within a line is to be honest with yourself about them and cull hard. But In the end Cull Buck it's your dog and all that matters is that you are happy with him. I certainly don't blame you for giving him another shot

I can support this totally.
The problem I personally have with "Catch Dogs" is that I haven't fully figured out what "my" standard is yet. I will admit that I havent had the same thought process and high standards with CD's as I have with curs. I use to have that "dime a dozen" attitude with them but not anymore.
Keep us updated on him Cullbuck.