What I don't want, is any outlaw hog dogger to have the RIGHT to come on to my property to retrieve their dog.
I agree, but an "outlaw hog dogger" is not what I would call retrieving a dog. That is more like backdoor hunting, but the laws are always open to interpretation...
I would have no problem with someone retrieving their dogs from my property without permission, but it isn't right for someone to try to use this loophole to try to hunt without permission.