I guess it depends one what kind of pack of dogs you want to have. Sounds like you like the real ruff gritty catch type when they find it. So if thats the case the dog is not doing the job you are looking for so I would not cull it I would find somebody and trade it for the kind of dog you are looking for which sounds like a pack of Find it catch it Running type of dogs that can find their on hog.
x2