My calve's are to big for muck boots. They cut off my circulation. The ones I linked to above I have wore for 4 or 5 years. Most of the camo has worn off by now. I do know lots of folks that like the muck boot tho. Biggest complaint I have heard is tread pattern doesn't offer enough grip.
Shotgun
Arkansas
Dang thats suprising, i may have a different model that what you have tried, only reason i say that is because they were one of they few my calves fit into good lol. Who knows, kinda like huntin dogs.... Find what works and stick with em.