The ultimate goal is keeping the best performing animal but without a crystal ball I just rely on looks, personality and gut feelings. Something that I'm a sucker for is if there is a pup who seems like he is near the top of the pecking order . . but without being the most aggressive. I think it's a confidence thing and the other pups know it without him having to bite holes in their ears. IMO . . confidence, self esteem, independence . . whatever you call it . . is a big factor in a dog being great versus being a decent representative of his pedigree
X2
If I had to choose at 6-8 weeks old, this would be my pick.
x3...
I have seen some aggressive pups that were just the opposite in the woods...and have seen some pups that stayed out the way and tried to get along with the bolder pups...and in the woods were more like catch dogs with a ton of bravery...
I like early starters with lots of natural ability and smart as well...
I have had some dogs I would put down with any dog any time...no off days and no excuses needed for these dogs...but I only have had a once in a lifetime dog one time...he amazed me at 10 weeks and never stopped after that...what set him apart even from the good ones was brain power...